As a Junior: Went 9-11 at #2 singles and 2-5 in MAAC play...Posted an 8-10 record in doubles play, including a 5-5 mark with classmate Jeremy Deuel at top doubles.
As a Sophomore: Played entire season at #2 singles, posting a 3-14 overall record but a 3-4 mark in MAAC play...Ended year 7-10 at top doubles playing exclusively with classmate Jeremy Deuel.
As a Freshman: Emerged as the team's #2 singles player as a rookie...Finished year with a 4-11 singles record which included a 3-11 mark at #2 singles...Played all 14 of his doubles matches at #1 doubles with Jeremy Deuel...The pair ended the season 5-9 overall and 2-4 in MAAC play.
Serbalik on Rutherford: "Nick is a naturally gifted player who simply loves to play the game. He has tremendous feel and is fearless at the net. He has teamed with Jeremy Deuel to become part of the most successful doubles team at Siena over the last 15 years."